Wisconsin Lost Treasure

Wisconsin lost treasure sites are listed on this page. However, I cannot promise that this information is completely accurate. As treasure tales go, because they have been passed down through many years, certain elements of the lost treasure story may have been altered, either intentionally or otherwise.

This information should be researched through other means as well. Never rely on one piece of information about a treasure story you are researching. Use multiple research tools.

For more information on where and how to research for lost treasures, please visit my research page.

Good luck! And have fun in your search for Wisconsin lost treasure.

The Great Milwaukee Fire in 1892 destroyed 26 acres of of homes. Some of the ruins from this fire still stand. Over the years treasure hunters have uncovered treasures and relics left from the fire.

Sheridan Park

The shores along this park have produced silver coins from the nineteenth century. The coins may be coming from the ships that sank over the years.

The Benjamin Noble Wreck

Located in Lake Superior. Gold coins have been found on the shore of Lake Superior. They are probably from the wreck Benjamin Noble, which was carrying $100,000 in gold coins.

Sand Island

Located in Lake Superior. A British officer, during the Revolutionary War, buried a chest of silver coins somewhere on Sand Island.

York Island

Located in Lake Superior. During the Revolutionary War British soldiers buried $128,000 in gold coins on this island. They buried the coins in an iron box to keep it from the Indians.

The William Wilson Treasure

Somewhere on Otter Island, in Lake Superior, William Wilson, a recluse, buried $90,000 in gold and silver coins. The treasure was buried near his cabin.

The Frederick Prentice Treasure

Somewhere on Hermit Island in Lake Superior, Frederick Prentice supposedly buried a large treasure near his home in 1895. The house is no longer standing.

Stockton Island

Located in Lake Superior. During the Revolutionary War, British soldiers were stealing from local residents. The soldiers then buried numerous caches on Stockton Island.

Little Bohemia Lodge

Located eight miles southeast of Mercer, on route 51. In 1934, the gangster John Dillinger was reported to have buried $700,000 in paper currency in the woods approximately one quarter mile behind the lodge.

The R.C. Bennett Treasure

When the very well to do businessman R.C. Bennett died in 1950, he wrote out instructions for his wife to various treasures he had buried. She found 60 tin boxes that held a total of $40,000. They were found beneath the basement floor of their home. Supposedly he had buried another million dollars that has never been recovered.

Wisconsin lost treasure may be located in ghost towns.